The Susceptibility Scale Transformation: Why You're Not Forever Stuck at Your Worst Moment

Thirty years. She hasn't binged in decades, but she's being asked to rate her current susceptibility based on her worst historical moment with food.

This is the fundamental flaw in the "once a pickle, always a pickle" philosophy that pervades much of the food addiction recovery world. And it's not just unhelpful—it's scientifically inaccurate and potentially harmful to your healing journey.

Take the Quiz Here: "What's REALLY Behind Your Food Choices?"

The Problem with Permanent Labels

When diet and abstinent programs ask you to rate your susceptibility based on your worst time with food—not where you are now, not your growth trajectory, not your current relationship with food—they're essentially asking you to define yourself by your lowest moment and carry that identity forward forever.

Imagine if we applied this logic to other areas of life:

• A person learning Spanish being asked to rate their language skills based on their very first Spanish class, when they couldn't even say "hello" properly—even though they now chat with their neighbors in Spanish every day
• Someone learning to drive being forever labeled based on that first terrifying lesson when they stalled at every stop sign—even though they now cruise through rush hour traffic without breaking a sweat
• A person who was painfully shy in high school being told they'll always be awkward in social situations—even though they now host dinner parties and love meeting new people
• Someone who failed algebra in 9th grade being told they'll never be good with numbers—even though they now run their own business and handle all the finances

We would never measure someone's skills today based on their early days of learning something. We cheer for progress and celebrate how far people have come. So why do we tell people their past food struggles define them now?

What Neuroscience Actually Tells Us

Here's what we know about the brain and addiction recovery:

Neuroplasticity Is Real and Ongoing

Your brain's ability to form new neural pathways doesn't stop working when it comes to food. Every time you choose a different response to stress than turning to food, every time you practice nervous system regulation, every time you reframe shame into curiosity—you're literally rewiring your brain's relationship with food.

The Susceptibility Scale Measures Current State, Not Permanent Capacity

When someone rates as a 1 or 2 on a susceptibility scale today, that's not them "managing" their permanent 10++ status. That's them having transformed their actual relationship with food through healing work.

Recovery Looks Different Than Management

There's a profound difference between:

• Managing a permanent condition (white-knuckling through cravings, rigid external control, constant vigilance)
• Transforming your relationship (genuine disinterest in trigger foods, internal wisdom guiding choices, peaceful coexistence with all foods)

via GIPHY

The Mosquito to Gnat Truth About Susceptibility

Here's what actually happens when you do deep food dysfunction recovery work:

Your physiological responses to certain substances don't disappear. If I ate ultra-processed foods again, the cravings and physical responses would return. My brain and body light up in all sorts of ways were I to eat ultra-processed foods. My gut biome would be out of balance. AND the neural pathways are still there, just dormant.

But your baseline relationship with those substances transforms. The constant mental noise goes from mosquito (urgent, disruptive, demanding immediate action) to gnat (occasional, manageable, easily redirected).

You develop what I call "healthy respect" rather than "abject fear." You avoid certain substances not because you're terrified of your own lack of control, but because you understand they don't serve your body's well-being, and you have zero interest in the way they make you feel.

My Susceptibility Scale Journey

When I first encountered the susceptibility scale, I was easily a 10++:

• Intense cravings that felt completely out of control
• Could eat entire packages of foods without consciousness
• Had tried and "failed" at countless approaches
• Used food as my primary coping mechanism

Today, I genuinely rate as a 1 or 2 on that same scale.

This isn't me "managing" my permanent 10++ status. This is actual transformation:

• I can have former trigger foods in my house without thinking about them
• I navigate social situations around food with genuine ease
• I have developed my own sacred boundaries... the Sonja approach to my food choices. 
• I experience stress without automatically turning to food
• I trust my body's signals completely

The key insight: I still choose to abstain from certain ultra-processed substances—not from fear, but from wisdom.

The Difference Between Fear-Based and Wisdom-Based Abstinence

Fear-based abstinence (the 10++ mindset):

• "I can't be around those foods because I have no control"
• "One bite and I'll completely relapse"
• "I need external rules to protect me from myself"
• "My brain is permanently wired for food dysfunction"
• Constant vigilance and anxiety around food

Wisdom-based abstinence (the transformed mindset):

• "I choose not to eat those foods because they don't serve my well-being"
• "I understand how those substances affect my body and brain"
• "I trust my internal wisdom to guide my choices"
• "My brain has learned new patterns that serve me better"
• Peaceful coexistence with all foods, conscious choices about what to consume

Why the "Permanent Susceptibility" Belief Is Harmful

It Creates Learned Helplessness

When you believe your susceptibility is fixed, you're less likely to invest in the deeper healing work that could actually transform it. Why work on nervous system regulation, trauma healing, or internal narrative shifts if you're told you'll always be a 10++?

It Reinforces External Locus of Control

The belief that you'll always need rigid external rules keeps you from developing the internal trust and wisdom that creates lasting transformation.

It Pathologizes Normal Healing Processes

It frames your nervous system's intelligent attempts to cope and adapt as permanent pathology rather than healable responses that can evolve.

It Ignores the Sophistication of Recovery

Real recovery involves complex neurobiological transformation, nervous system healing, trauma resolution, and identity shifts. Reducing this to "management of permanent dysfunction" misses the profound nature of what's actually possible.

The Revolutionary Truth: Susceptibility Is Trainable

Your current susceptibility rating describes your present patterns, not your permanent capacity.

Just like you can train your brain to:

• Speak new languages
• Develop new skills
• Recover from trauma
• Build emotional regulation abilities
• Create new habit patterns

You can train your brain to have a completely different relationship with food.

This doesn't mean the work is easy or happens overnight. Neuroplasticity requires consistent practice, patience, and often support. But it means your current relationship with food is not your destiny.

What Transformation Actually Looks Like

When someone has genuinely transformed their susceptibility (not just managed it), you'll notice:

Decreased Mental Preoccupation: Food thoughts are background noise, not front-and-center obsession.

Genuine Disinterest: Former trigger foods lose their magnetic appeal—not through willpower, but through authentic lack of interest.

Flexible Responses: They can navigate unexpected food situations without internal chaos or rigid rule-following.

Body Trust: They rely on internal cues rather than external rules to guide eating decisions.

Peaceful Social Navigation: Food-related social situations don't require extensive preparation or recovery time.

Wise Boundaries: They make conscious choices about what to consume based on how foods make them feel, not from fear of losing control.

The Gnat-Level Life

When your food patterns have transformed from mosquito to gnat level, something remarkable happens: you've developed new pathways, new automatic responses. You're not fighting the old urges—you've literally created different routes through your day.

It's like that old story about walking down the street. At first, you keep falling in the same hole over and over. You can't figure out how to get out, you blame the hole, you try to jump over it. Eventually, you realize—oh wait, I can just take a different street entirely.

That's what gnat-level transformation looks like: you've built new streets.

Here's what those new pathways actually sound like:

"I'm feeling stressed... I think I'll step outside for a minute" (instead of automatically heading to the kitchen)

"There's ice cream in the freezer" (neutral observation, like noting there's also laundry detergent in the utility room—your brain just doesn't go there anymore)

"Everyone's getting donuts... I think I'll grab some water instead" (not because you're being "good," but because that's just what feels right now)

"I could grab some of that birthday cake, but honestly, I feel really good right now and I'd rather keep this energy going" (your brain has learned to value how you feel more than momentary taste)

This isn't about having superhuman willpower or being afraid of "losing control." You've literally rewired your automatic responses. The old pathway (stress → food) still exists somewhere in your brain, but you've worn a deeper groove in the new pathway (stress → what do I actually need right now?).

The noise has turned down because you're not even walking down that street anymore.

Your brain has learned that there are other ways to handle stress, celebrate, transition between activities, or just take a break. Food is just not your brain's first, second, or third suggestion anymore.

Honoring Both Truths

Here's what I believe is true simultaneously:

1. Certain substances will always have physiological effects on susceptible people. The neural pathways for ultra-processed food responses don't disappear entirely.
2. Your baseline relationship with those substances can transform. The urgency, preoccupation, and emotional charge can shift from mosquito to gnat level.
3. Informed abstinence is different from fearful restriction. You can choose not to consume certain substances from a place of body wisdom rather than terror of your own responses.
4. Healing is possible without being "cured." You can transform your susceptibility while maintaining healthy respect for substances that don't serve your well-being.

Your Transformation Is Valid

If you used to struggle intensely with food and now you don't, that transformation is real and valid. You're not "managing" a permanent condition—you've grown, healed, and evolved, enough, to recognize the peace.

If you still choose to avoid certain foods, that doesn't mean you're "still addicted." It means you've developed the wisdom to understand what serves your body and what doesn't. A healthy respect for what those substances can and will do to your body.

If your relationship with food has genuinely transformed, don't let anyone convince you that you're still the same person you were at your lowest point. Growth is real. Healing is possible. Change is the nature of being human.

Your susceptibility scale rating is your starting point, not your permanent identity.

The most radical act in food dysfunction recovery? Believing in your own capacity to change.

Ready to Discover Your ACTUAL Food Relationship Patterns?

If this resonates with you, I invite you to take my Food Relationship Quiz—one that measures where you are RIGHT NOW, not where you were at your lowest point.

This quiz reveals:

• Your current relationship with food (not your historical worst)
• How much you've already transformed (even if you don't realize it)
• The specific patterns that are still active vs. the ones that have become background noise
• Your unique blueprint for continued growth

Take the Quiz Here: "What's REALLY Behind Your Food Choices?"

It takes just a few minutes and gives you a completely different perspective on your relationship with food—one based on your growth and current reality, not your past struggles.

The Full Story: Coming Soon

This blog post is just the beginning. I'm putting the finishing touches on my book "Thinking Outside the Box: A Revolutionary Approach to Food Dysfunction" which dives deep into:

• Why traditional approaches keep people stuck in permanent "patient" identities
• The science of how food relationships actually transform
• Specific strategies for different pattern types (not one-size-fits-all solutions)
• How to recognize and celebrate your own mosquito-to-gnat transformations
• The difference between managing dysfunction and creating genuine food freedom

Want to be first to know when it's available?

After you take the quiz, you'll get updates about the book launch plus ongoing insights about food relationship transformation that you won't find anywhere else.

Your transformation is real. Your growth matters. Your current relationship with food—not your past struggles—defines your path forward.

Ready to see how far you've actually come?

Take the Quiz | Get Book Updates